Analysing The Greatest Newcastle United Starting 11

Published by Chris Jenkins
27th Jun 2023

Newcastle United is a club steeped in rich history and tradition, boasting a passionate fanbase and a legacy of iconic players. Over the years, the club has witnessed the rise of remarkable talents who have left an indelible mark on the field of play. Assembling a dream starting 11 from the club's illustrious history is a challenging yet exciting endeavour. In this blog post, we embark on the journey of analysing and dissecting the greatest Newcastle United starting 11.

This starting 11 is a collection of legendary figures who have graced the hallowed turf of St. James' Park and etched their names into the hearts of Newcastle United supporters. From formidable strikers to creative midfield maestros, solid defenders to reliable goalkeepers, each player chosen for this lineup has significantly contributed to the club's success and left an enduring legacy.

As we delve into the analysis of this esteemed starting 11, we will explore the remarkable careers and achievements of these players. We will unravel the magic they brought to the pitch, relive their memorable moments of brilliance, and highlight their impact in shaping Newcastle United's history. From iconic goals to awe-inspiring saves, and intricate passes to resolute defensive displays, each player has played a crucial role in the club's fortunes.

Moreover, we cannot overlook the influential managers who have guided Newcastle United to success, providing the tactical acumen and leadership necessary for the team's achievements. Their ability to mould and inspire players, coupled with their astute decision-making on the touchline, has played a significant role in shaping the team's style of play and the club's identity.

Join us as we delve into the analysis of the greatest Newcastle United starting 11, celebrating the remarkable talents who have graced the black-and-white stripes. Together, we will honour the achievements of these legendary figures and relish the memories they have gifted us, paying homage to their contributions to the illustrious history of Newcastle United Football Club.


The Forwards

Newcastle United has been blessed with an array of exceptional forwards who have delighted fans with their goalscoring prowess and attacking flair. In this section, we explore the strikers who have made a significant impact on the club's history.

One name that stands out is Alan Shearer, the all-time leading goalscorer in the Premier League. Shearer's arrival at Newcastle United in 1996 brought immense excitement to the club and its fans. His lethal finishing, physical presence, and leadership qualities made him a formidable force in the Premier League. Shearer's ability to find the back of the net with astonishing consistency earned him a place in the hearts of Newcastle United supporters.

Another notable forward is Les Ferdinand, who formed a lethal partnership with Shearer during the mid-1990s. Ferdinand possessed a combination of pace, power, and technical ability that made him a nightmare for defenders. His goalscoring exploits contributed significantly to Newcastle United's attacking potency and helped the team achieve notable successes.

In more recent times, Newcastle United has witnessed the impact of strikers like Demba Ba and Papiss Cissé. Their goal-scoring exploits and ability to produce moments of brilliance endeared them to the fans. Their contributions helped propel the club to memorable victories and solidified their place in Newcastle United's striking folklore.

While this starting 11 focuses on the forwards, it is important to acknowledge the overall attacking contributions of players like Peter Beardsley, who played as an attacking midfielder. Beardsley's vision, creativity, and exquisite passing ability made him a key playmaker for Newcastle United. His ability to unlock defences and provide assists added an extra dimension to the team's attacking play.

The combination of prolific goalscorers and skilled playmakers in Newcastle United's forward line has been instrumental in the club's success over the years. Their ability to find the back of the net with precision and entertain fans with their individual brilliance has left an indelible mark on the history of the club.


The Midfielders

In the midfield, Newcastle United has witnessed the presence of influential figures who have brought creativity, vision, and control to the team. These midfield maestros have left an indelible mark on the club's history, contributing to Newcastle United's attacking potency and playing a pivotal role in the team's success.

One prominent name that immediately comes to mind is Peter Beardsley. Operating as an attacking midfielder, Beardsley possessed exquisite skill and a footballing brain that allowed him to unlock defences with ease. His vision, precise passing, and ability to create scoring opportunities made him an integral part of Newcastle United's attacking play. Beardsley's contribution to the team's success cannot be overstated, and he remains a revered figure in the club's folklore.

Additionally, the midfield saw the likes of Kevin Keegan, who not only served as a player but also as a manager for the club. Keegan's energy, determination, and ability to dictate the tempo of the game made him a fan favourite. His presence in the midfield was instrumental in driving the team forward and creating opportunities for the forwards.

Furthermore, the modern era has witnessed the emergence of influential midfielders such as Yohan Cabaye and Jonjo Shelvey. Cabaye's technical ability, range of passing, and eye for goal made him a vital cog in Newcastle United's midfield engine. Similarly, Shelvey's passing range, long-range shooting, and ability to control the tempo of the game have made him a key figure in recent years.

The contribution of these midfield maestros extends beyond their individual brilliance. Their ability to link defence with attack, maintain possession, and create goal-scoring opportunities has been pivotal in shaping the style and identity of Newcastle United. The midfielders' creative genius and ability to control the rhythm of the game have provided the foundation for the team's success on numerous occasions.

As we analyse the greatest Newcastle United starting 11, it is crucial to acknowledge the impact of these midfield maestros who have mesmerised fans, inspired their teammates, and contributed significantly to the club's illustrious history. Their vision, skill, and ability to dictate play have left an indelible mark on the Newcastle United faithful and have ensured their place among the greatest players to have donned the black-and-white jersey.


The Defenders

Newcastle United has witnessed the presence of resolute defenders, who have provided a solid foundation at the back and played pivotal roles in the club's success. These defenders have exhibited exceptional defensive skills, leadership qualities, and a commitment to keeping the opposition at bay.

One standout figure is the legendary Bobby Moncur, who captained Newcastle United to their famous 1969 Inter-Cities Fairs Cup triumph. Moncur's strength, aerial ability, and no-nonsense defending made him a revered figure among the fans. His leadership on and off the pitch showcased the true spirit of Newcastle United and left an enduring legacy.

In recent times, the emergence of Jamaal Lascelles has brought stability and resilience to the backline. Lascelles' commanding presence, aerial prowess, and ability to organise the defence have made him a key figure in Newcastle United's recent successes. His leadership as captain has inspired the team and instilled a sense of unity within the squad.

Alongside these iconic defenders, Newcastle United has witnessed the contributions of full-backs who have provided defensive solidity as well as attacking impetus. Players like Kieran Trippier have displayed their versatility and defensive prowess while also contributing to the team's attacking play with their overlapping runs and accurate crosses.

The defenders chosen for the greatest Newcastle United starting 11 have not only showcased exceptional defensive skills but have also embodied the fighting spirit and commitment to the cause that defines the club. Their ability to keep opposition attacks at bay, organise the defence, and contribute to the team's overall balance has played crucial roles in Newcastle United's success throughout the years.


The Goalkeeper

No starting 11 is complete without a reliable and skilled goalkeeper, and Newcastle United has seen the presence of exceptional shot-stoppers who have provided security between the posts. One such notable figure is Shay Given, who was a formidable presence in goal for Newcastle United. Given's shot-stopping abilities, agility, and consistency earned him a reputation as one of the best goalkeepers in the Premier League during his time at the club. His remarkable saves and commanding presence instilled confidence in the team's defence.

The selection of these exceptional goalkeepers highlights their significant role in maintaining Newcastle United's defensive stability and instilling confidence in the team. Their ability to make crucial saves, command their area, and distribute the ball effectively has made them indispensable figures in the club's history.



In conclusion, the Newcastle United starting 11, comprised of the greatest players in the club's history, showcases the incredible talent, passion, and success that have graced St. James' Park. From legendary figures like Alan Shearer, Peter Beardsley, and Kevin Keegan to recent stars like Allan Saint-Maximin and Callum Wilson, each player has left an indelible mark on the club and its devoted fanbase.

The striking prowess of Alan Shearer, complemented by the creative genius of Peter Beardsley and the leadership of Kevin Keegan, defined an era of success and excitement for Newcastle United. Their contributions to the Premier League, combined with the goalscoring prowess of Les Ferdinand and the tenacity of Sean Longstaff, have created unforgettable memories for the faithful supporters.

Defensively, the likes of Steve Bruce, Kieran Trippier, and Sven Botman have provided a solid foundation at the back, while the acrobatic saves of Shay Given and the commanding presence of Pavel Srníček ensured a formidable last line of defence. Their commitment and defensive resilience have contributed to memorable victories and helped secure the club's position in the Premier League.

In the midfield, the creativity of Peter Beardsley, the energy of Allan Saint-Maximin, and the midfield command of Sean Longstaff have brought balance and flair to the team. These midfield maestros have thrilled fans with their technical ability, vision, and goal-scoring prowess, epitomising the spirit of Newcastle United.

As Newcastle United looks to the future under the leadership of Eddie Howe, the potential for new stars like Joe Willock and Dan Burn to make their mark in the starting XI brings excitement and anticipation. The legacy of the iconic figures who have donned the black-and-white jersey, from Alan Shearer to Alan Shearer and Kevin Keegan to Les Ferdinand, continues to inspire and ignite the passion of the club's loyal supporters.

With a storied history and a passionate fanbase, Newcastle United's iconic players and their contributions to the Premier League will forever be etched in football folklore. From the historic St. James' Park to the thrilling moments of triumph and heartbreak, the Newcastle United starting 11 embodies the essence of the club and its unwavering pursuit of success.

Whether it's the roar of the crowd, the goals that shake the stadium, or the moments of brilliance that leave fans in awe, the Newcastle United starting 11 represents the best of the best. They embody the spirit, determination, and pride of Newcastle United Football Club, forever etching their names in the club's history and capturing the hearts of the devoted fans who fill the iconic St. James' Park.